For dessert lovers and loyal Costco shoppers, one burning question arises each year: “Does Costco have Key Lime Pies now?” This iconic pie has a cult following and often causes a frenzy among customers when it makes its seasonal return. Known for its large size, tangy filling, and great value, Costco’s Key Lime Pie remains a top choice for summer gatherings.
In this guide, we’ll cover everything you need to know about Costco’s Key Lime Pie, including its availability, pricing, taste, and tips to secure one before it sells out. We’ll also provide helpful comparisons with similar pies and suggest related dessert ideas to try at home.
What Is Costco’s Key Lime Pie?
Costco’s Key Lime Pie is a legendary dessert that has earned its place in Costco’s seasonal bakery lineup. Featuring a buttery graham cracker crust, a creamy and tangy key lime filling, and a fluffy whipped topping, this pie delivers a perfect balance of flavors.
At 4.25 pounds, it’s a dessert that can serve up to 12-16 people, making it ideal for parties and large gatherings. Additionally, it’s a budget-friendly option, typically priced between $14.99 and $16.99 depending on location. Because it’s a limited-time offer, it often sells out quickly, so fans eagerly await its return each year.
Unlike some store-bought pies that rely on artificial flavors, Costco’s version tastes fresh and homemade. Therefore, it’s no surprise that many customers consider it one of the best key lime pies on the market.
Is Costco’s Key Lime Pie Available Now?
Yes, it is! As of early 2025, reports from Instagram and TikTok confirm that Costco’s Key Lime Pie has made a return. Fans have shared sightings from various locations, particularly in California, Texas, and Florida, where the pie has been spotted on store shelves.
However, availability varies by region. Therefore, it’s wise to check with your local Costco store before heading out. If you prefer convenience, you can also order through delivery services like Instacart, where the pie may be available for curbside pickup or same-day delivery.
Why Is Costco’s Key Lime Pie So Popular?
There’s a reason why Costco’s Key Lime Pie flies off the shelves whenever it returns. Several key factors contribute to its popularity:
1. Large Size and Great Value
One of the biggest selling points of Costco’s bakery items is their size and affordability. The Key Lime Pie is no exception.
Weighing over 4 pounds, this dessert is large enough to feed a crowd. At under $17, it’s also an incredible bargain, with each slice costing less than $2 per serving. Therefore, it’s a top choice for those hosting summer barbecues or family gatherings.
Additionally, Costco’s reputation for offering high-quality baked goods at reasonable prices makes this pie even more desirable.
2. Authentic Flavor Profile
Unlike many store-bought pies that use artificial lime flavoring, Costco’s version tastes authentic and refreshing. The filling is made with real key lime juice, which gives it a zesty tang that balances perfectly with the sweetness of the crust and whipped topping.
Additionally, the graham cracker crust provides a buttery crunch that contrasts well with the creamy filling. The light whipped topping adds a final touch of sweetness, ensuring a well-rounded flavor experience.
Compared to other key lime pies, Costco’s version stands out for its homemade taste and quality ingredients.
How Does Costco’s Key Lime Pie Compare to Competitors?
If you’re wondering how Costco’s Key Lime Pie stacks up against competitors like Trader Joe’s and Publix, here’s a quick comparison:
| Brand | Price | Size | Flavor Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Costco | $14.99-$16.99 | 4.25 lbs | Creamy, tangy, refreshing |
| Trader Joe’s | $6.99 | 17 oz | Tart, smaller size |
| Publix | $10.99 | 32 oz | Sweet, less tangy |
While Trader Joe’s offers a more tart option and Publix delivers a sweeter pie, Costco’s version wins in terms of size, value, and balanced flavor.
Social Media Buzz Around Costco’s Key Lime Pie
Every time Costco’s Key Lime Pie returns, it creates a social media buzz. Fans flock to platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and Reddit to share photos, reviews, and excitement over its comeback.
For instance, the hashtag #CostcoKeyLimePie has garnered thousands of posts, featuring customers showing off their purchases or sharing serving suggestions. Additionally, TikTok videos showcasing taste tests often go viral, increasing demand for the pie.
Therefore, it’s no surprise that the pie tends to sell out quickly, especially when it’s first spotted in stores.
Tips for Securing a Costco Key Lime Pie
Given the pie’s popularity, it’s essential to act fast if you want to get your hands on one. Here are some practical tips to ensure you don’t miss out:
- Visit early in the day: Costco’s bakery items tend to sell out by the afternoon, so plan your trip accordingly.
- Check multiple locations: Availability can vary by store, so it’s worth visiting more than one Costco if needed.
- Order online: Use services like Instacart to order for delivery or curbside pickup.
Additionally, keeping an eye on social media updates from Costco fan pages can help you stay informed about when the pie is back in stock.
Nutritional Information of Costco’s Key Lime Pie
While delicious, Costco’s Key Lime Pie is a high-calorie dessert that should be enjoyed in moderation. Here’s a quick breakdown of its nutritional content:
| Nutrient | Per Serving (1/12 of the pie) |
|---|---|
| Calories | 320 |
| Total Fat | 16g |
| Sugars | 27g |
| Protein | 4g |
Therefore, if you’re watching your calorie intake, consider enjoying smaller portions or sharing the pie with family and friends.
FAQs About Costco’s Key Lime Pie
Here are some frequently asked questions about Costco’s Key Lime Pie:
1. Is Costco’s Key Lime Pie Available Year-Round?
No, it’s typically a seasonal item available during the warmer months of spring and summer.
2. How Long Does Costco’s Key Lime Pie Last?
The pie lasts about 3-5 days in the refrigerator after purchase.
3. Can You Freeze Costco’s Key Lime Pie?
Yes, the pie can be frozen for up to 2 months. Just make sure to wrap it tightly to prevent freezer burn.
Final Thoughts: Should You Try Costco’s Key Lime Pie?
If you’re a fan of key lime desserts, Costco’s Key Lime Pie is a must-try. Its large size, great value, and authentic flavor make it an excellent dessert for gatherings or satisfying your sweet tooth.
For more Costco dessert options, don’t forget to check out Does Costco Sell Chocolate Lava Cakes?.